Trump voters in key state say it’s Clinton who’s deplorable
By David Lightman and Anita Kumar
McClatchy Washington Bureau
September 14, 2016 07:07 PM
Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton arrives to speak to members of the media before boarding her campaign plane at Westchester County Airport in White Plains, N.Y., on Thursday, Sept. 8, 2016, to travel to Charlotte, N.C., to attend a campaign rally. Andrew HarnikAP
SCRANTON, PA.
Debra Gulvas voted for Hillary Clinton in 2008, hoping to see the United States elect its first female president.
But she left the Democratic Party last spring and now supports Donald Trump. Clinton’s recent remark that half of Trump’s supporters are a “basket of deplorables” only served to solidify Gulvas’ choice.
“She’s calling everyone a name,” said Gulvas, a retired Social Security supervisor from Plymouth, Pennsylvania. “She’s insulting all of America.”
Less than two months before the election, Clinton may find that that describing half her opponent’s backers as “deplorables” may hurt her – and energize white working-class voters in swing states such as Pennsylvania who were already leaning toward Trump.
For many, the comment reinforces the notion that Clinton is a wealthy elitist who can’t relate to the lower- and middle-class families who make up much of the electorate in Pennsylvania, Ohio and Michigan.
Chet Koske, who works at a Scranton diner, said he’d heard a lot of talk this week about the Clinton comment — none of it positive.
Does he think Clinton was insulting him? “Definitely,” said Koske, who said he was leaning toward voting for Trump.
Clinton made the comment Friday at a New York fundraiser, saying Trump’s base was split between people seeking a change and a group of racist, sexist, homophobic or xenophobic Americans.
She quickly said she regretted being “grossly generalistic” but that she would continue to speak out about bigotry and racist rhetoric during the campaign.
September 10, 2016
">
“I’m not racist. I’m not homophobic. I have an uncle who’s gay,” said Mike Santos, a Dunmore diesel mechanic and independent voter who is leaning toward Trump.
Republicans have spent days criticizing Clinton for words that they say insulted average American voters. Trump, who himself frequently insults large groups of the population, called the language from Clinton the “biggest mistake” of the campaign season.
“The disdain that Hillary Clinton expressed toward millions of Americans disqualifies her from public service,” Trump said this week. “You cannot run for president if you have such contempt in your heart for the American voter. You can't lead this nation if you have such a low opinion of its citizens.”
September 10, 2016
">
Marissa Ritter, a motor truck company service adviser who remains undecided, said candidates “should be talking about things that matter instead of acting like middle school kids.”
Clinton’s remarks came two days before she abruptly departed a 9/11 ceremony in New York. She was caught on camera stumbling and struggling to walk as she was helped into a waiting vehicle.
She caused an uproar by ditching her press corps and waiting 90 minutes to offer a partial explanation of what had happened. It wasn’t until hours later that Clinton’s campaign announced she had been diagnosed with pneumonia two days earlier and released a statement from her doctor.
Hank Sheinkopf, a New York-based consultant who once worked for Clinton, said her health took the potentially more damaging issue of “deplorables” off the front page.
“It reinforces that she’s not one of them . . . that she’s an elitist who doesn’t know how people feel,” he said. “That’s not helpful to her.”
EDITORS: BEGIN OPTIONAL TRIM
Some Republicans quickly compared Clinton’s remark to a comment that Republican then-presidential-candidate Mitt Romney made four years ago about 47 percent of Americans being dependent on the federal government, though it’s unclear whether it will have as much damage.
“What she said was very offensive,” said Tim Bryant, a Honesdale mechanic who voted for Barack Obama in 2008. “She's an elitist.”
EDITORS: END OPTIONAL TRIM
I see right through her now.
Debra Gulvas, a retiree from Plymouth, Pa.
Voters here appeared less worried that Clinton was slow to respond to health questions and much more concerned about the “deplorable” comment. Independent voters said they were troubled by the remarks, and those already leaning toward Trump said they felt more strongly about their candidate.
“She segregates herself from everybody else,” said Gloria Gebert, a Canaan Township beauty salon owner who is a Republican. “She thinks other people are beneath her.”
Some Democrats praised Clinton for quickly saying she regretted the phrase while others said it could actually help her with those likely to support her who might not be enthusiastic enough to get to the polls.
“In any campaign you’re going to say something that appears too sharp,” said P.J. Crowley, who was a State Department spokesman under Clinton.
Crowley said Trump’s running mate, Mike Pence, had helped Clinton by refusing to call former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke deplorable. Speaking on CNN, Pence said he and Trump didn’t want Duke’s support but that he wouldn’t engage in name-calling.
Antoinette Romano, a retired legal aide from Lackawaxen who’d voted for Clinton’s husband, President Bill Clinton, said Hillary Clinton’s comments reaffirmed her decision to turn away from the party. “Her comment was asinine, the stupidest thing I ever heard,” she said.
California Republican Party Chair Jim Brulte is sounding a warning on the GOP needing to appeal more to Asian and Latino Americans. California House Republicans don’t know how to do that.